Here is what I found at my local Goodwill. I spent $3 on the Cheese Dome and $1.50 on the Candlestick.
The boys and I ran to Lowe's and picked up some spray paint (I used a high gloss but satin would work fine, too!), a sanding block and some super glue gel. I spent $10.00 on these products, but most people probably have these things in their garage. Our garage is just in utter chaos right now with the move.
I lightly sanded everything and then gave it a generous spray with the paint. After it dried I used the sanding block lightly around the edges to give it a distressed look.
This was the final product!